SOC vs MDR Piergiorgio Venuti

SOC vs MDR: Complete Guide to Comparing Security Operations Center and Managed Detection and Response

Estimated reading time: 3 minutes

The comparison between SOC and MDR is crucial when evaluating options for threat monitoring and response. But what are the key differences between an internal Security Operations Center and an external Managed Detection and Response service? This guide provides a detailed analysis of SOC vs MDR.

What is a SOC?

A Security Operations Center (SOC) is an internal facility dedicated to monitoring, analyzing, and responding to security incidents. A team of cybersecurity professionals oversees the network 24/7 looking for malicious activity using a combination of processes and technology like SIEM and Threat Intelligence.

The main tasks of a SOC include monitoring security events, investigating alerts, threat hunting, information sharing, and reporting to business leaders. SOCs can be fully in-house or partially outsourced to external providers.

When to Implement an Internal SOC

Determining whether an internal SOC or external MDR service is more suitable depends on an organization’s specific security needs and maturity.

Internal SOCs are ideal for larger companies with the budget for advanced tools and qualified teams.

MDRs are recommended for SMBs seeking to expand their cybersecurity capabilities flexibly.

Highly regulated organizations can benefit from the threat hunting capabilities of MDRs.

hybrid SOC + MDR model provides the best of both options for many companies.

How to Build an Effective SOC

Building an effective SOC requires significant investments in strategy, technology, people, and processes:

  • Clearly define the mandate based on business and cybersecurity objectives.
  • Choose the right mix of in-house resources and external services.

Choosing Appropriate SOC Technology

  • Implement powerful SIEM, analytics, and automation tools.
  • Integrate multiple data sources for full visibility.

Defining Mature SOC Processes

  • Document and refine standardized procedures for each activity.
  • Apply frameworks like NIST for process maturity.
  • Regularly review and improve processes.

What is an MDR Service?

A Managed Detection and Response (MDR) service is a managed security solution provided by external vendors to augment the capabilities of an in-house SOC team. MDRs go beyond just monitoring to include advanced threat detection, in-depth investigation, and automated incident response powered by specialized expertise and technology.

MDRs serve as a proactive extension of internal security teams, identifying and neutralizing the most sophisticated cyber-threats. They provide on-demand expertise to complement an organization’s existing resources.

Key Differences Between SOC and MDR

  • SOCs often have limited scope, while MDRs monitor the entire attack surface.
  • SOCs take a more reactive, passive approach to security, MDRs are proactive.
  • Analysis in SOCs focuses on event correlation, MDRs perform real threat hunting and investigation.

When to Choose an MDR Service

MDRs are recommended for SMBs seeking to expand their cybersecurity capabilities flexibly.

Highly regulated organizations can benefit from the threat hunting capabilities of MDRs.

Choosing an MDR Service

To select a high-quality MDR service, it’s essential to evaluate several key criteria:

  • Analyze monitoring, detection, investigation, and response capabilities.
  • Verify analyst credentials and experience.
  • Assess technologies and security tools used.

Conclusion

Thoroughly comparing SOC vs MDR is critical to finding the optimal cyber defense strategy by combining the strengths of both approaches.

Useful links:

Share


RSS

More Articles…

Categories …

Tags

RSS darkreading

RSS Full Disclosure

  • SEC Consult SA-20240220-0 :: Multiple Stored Cross-Site Scripting Vulnerabilities in OpenOLAT (Frentix GmbH) February 21, 2024
    Posted by SEC Consult Vulnerability Lab, Research via Fulldisclosure on Feb 20SEC Consult Vulnerability Lab Security Advisory < 20240220-0 > ======================================================================= title: Multiple Stored Cross-Site Scripting Vulnerabilities product: OpenOLAT (Frentix GmbH) vulnerable version:
  • Re: Buffer Overflow in graphviz via via a crafted config6a file February 21, 2024
    Posted by Matthew Fernandez on Feb 20The fix for this ended up landing in Graphviz 10.0.1, available at https://graphviz.org/download/. Details of this CVE (CVE-2023-46045) are now published, but the CPEs are incomplete. For those who track such things, the affected range is [2.36.0, 10.0.1).
  • CVE-2024-24681: Insecure AES key in Yealink Configuration Encrypt Tool February 21, 2024
    Posted by Jeroen J.A.W. Hermans via Fulldisclosure on Feb 20CloudAware Security Advisory CVE-2024-24681: Insecure AES key in Yealink Configuration Encrypt Tool ======================================================================== Summary ======================================================================== A single, vendorwide, hardcoded AES key in the configuration tool used to encrypt provisioning documents was leaked leading to a compromise of confidentiality of provisioning documents....
  • Microsoft Windows Defender / Backdoor:JS/Relvelshe.A / Detection Mitigation Bypass February 21, 2024
    Posted by hyp3rlinx on Feb 20[+] Credits: John Page (aka hyp3rlinx) [+] Website: hyp3rlinx.altervista.org [+] Source: https://hyp3rlinx.altervista.org/advisories/Windows_Defender_Backdoor_JS.Relvelshe.A_Detection_Mitigation_Bypass.txt [+] twitter.com/hyp3rlinx [+] ISR: ApparitionSec [Vendor] www.microsoft.com [Product] Windows Defender [Vulnerability Type] Detection Mitigation Bypass Backdoor:JS/Relvelshe.A [CVE Reference] N/A [Security Issue] Back in 2022 I released a...
  • Microsoft Windows Defender / VBScript Detection Bypass February 21, 2024
    Posted by hyp3rlinx on Feb 20[+] Credits: John Page (aka hyp3rlinx) [+] Website: hyp3rlinx.altervista.org [+] Source: https://hyp3rlinx.altervista.org/advisories/MICROSOFT_WINDOWS_DEFENDER_VBSCRIPT_TROJAN_MITIGATION_BYPASS.txt [+] twitter.com/hyp3rlinx [+] ISR: ApparitionSec [Vendor] www.microsoft.com [Product] Windows Defender [Vulnerability Type] Windows Defender VBScript Detection Mitigation Bypass TrojanWin32Powessere.G [CVE Reference] N/A [Security Issue]...
  • Microsoft Windows Defender / Trojan.Win32/Powessere.G / Detection Mitigation Bypass Part 3 February 21, 2024
    Posted by hyp3rlinx on Feb 20[+] Credits: John Page (aka hyp3rlinx) [+] Website: hyp3rlinx.altervista.org [+] Source: https://hyp3rlinx.altervista.org/advisories/MICROSOFT_WINDOWS_DEFENDER_TROJAN.WIN32.POWESSERE.G_MITIGATION_BYPASS_PART_3.txt [+] twitter.com/hyp3rlinx [+] ISR: ApparitionSec [Vendor] www.microsoft.com [Product] Windows Defender [Vulnerability Type] Windows Defender Detection Mitigation Bypass TrojanWin32Powessere.G [CVE Reference] N/A [Security Issue]...
  • 44CON 2024 September 18th - 20th CFP February 15, 2024
    Posted by Florent Daigniere via Fulldisclosure on Feb 1544CON is the UK&apos;s largest combined annual Security Conference and Training event. Taking place 18,19,20 of September at the Novotel London West near Hammersmith, London. We will have a fully dedicated conference facility, including catering, private bar, amazing coffee and a daily Gin O’Clock break.         _  […]
  • SEC Consult SA-20240212-0 :: Multiple Stored Cross-Site Scripting vulnerabilities in Statamic CMS February 14, 2024
    Posted by SEC Consult Vulnerability Lab, Research via Fulldisclosure on Feb 13SEC Consult Vulnerability Lab Security Advisory < 20240212-0 > ======================================================================= title: Multiple Stored Cross-Site Scripting vulnerabilities product: Statamic CMS vulnerable version: =3.4.17 CVE number: CVE-2024-24570 impact: high homepage: https://statamic.com/...
  • Stored XSS and RCE - adaptcmsv3.0.3 February 14, 2024
    Posted by Andrey Stoykov on Feb 13# Exploit Title: Stored XSS and RCE - adaptcmsv3.0.3 # Date: 02/2024 # Exploit Author: Andrey Stoykov # Version: 3.0.3 # Tested on: Ubuntu 22.04 # Blog: http://msecureltd.blogspot.com *Description* - It was found that adaptcms v3.0.3 was vulnerable to stored cross site scripting - Also the application allowed the […]
  • OXAS-ADV-2023-0007: OX App Suite Security Advisory February 14, 2024
    Posted by Martin Heiland via Fulldisclosure on Feb 13Dear subscribers, We&apos;re sharing our latest advisory with you and like to thank everyone who contributed in finding and solving those vulnerabilities. Feel free to join our bug bounty programs for OX App Suite, Dovecot and PowerDNS at YesWeHack. This advisory has also been published at https://documentation.open-xchange.com/appsuite/security/advisories/html/2023/oxas-adv-2023-0007.html. […]

Customers

Newsletter

{subscription_form_1}